Book Review: On the Oceans of Eternity by S.M. Stirling

Well, here we are at last. The final book in the Island in the Sea of Time trilogy. I'm very pleased to see that these reviews having been doing very well. Okay then, I guess there really isn’t anything left for me to say. Let's get straight to it. We're taking a look at On the Oceans of Eternity by S.M. Stirling.

It is the moment everything has been building up towards. The time displaced Republic of Nantucket and its allies are about to face-off against the empire of the tyrannical madman William Walker. This is no small task, and it's going to take every trick in Nantucket's arsenal to pull-off. There are plenty of twists, turns, and surprises as past and present collide on the oceans of eternity.

Well, what can I say to start about On the Oceans of Eternity? It hits some of the highest notes in the series, but it also has some of my least favorite moments in the series. Let's start with some of the positives. So, Against the Tide of Years ended with Walker's Achaean army arriving at the Gates of Troy. My friend Jordan Harbour, founder of the Twilight Histories podcast, once spoke about the Island in the Time series and said "If you've ever wondered what The Iliad would be like if Odysseus had a bazooka, look no further." I should mention that Jordan is a big fan of the Island in the Sea of Time series. In fact, he listed it as one of the series that got him into alternate history. Jordan also cites the Worldwar series and Guns of the South, both by Harry Turtledove, as major influences on him.

Now, we do get at least some of that sort of stuff. However, the Siege of Troy didn't last as long as I was expecting. In fact, Walker's troops pretty much steamrolled the Trojans. Well, I guess if nothing else, at least the Greeks won like history and mythology said they were supposed to. Granted, they were being led by Walker; then again, most figures from Greek Mythology weren't exactly nice by modern standards. Of course, the Trojan War ending that quickly isn't going to make for a very long, or very engaging, epic poem.

Ian gets taken back to Walkeropolis as a hostage. Among other developments, Alice Wong has started a cult called the Claws of Hekate. It emphasizes the virtues of activities such as human sacrifice, torture, cannibalism, and other horrific acts. The Claws of Hekate has proved disturbingly popular among upper class Achaean women. Wong also has a trained team of teenage girls to serve as warriors and assassins for the Claws of Hekate. Walker jokingly refers to them as Wong's Sailor Moon Platoon. Wong says something to the effect of "Never doubt the power of manga scholarship, William."

There's also a part where Wong briefly mentions how she enjoys the taste of long pig, and how only long veal steak comes close to rivaling it. Wait a minute, does that mean...oh no, this is terrible! The only confirmed anime and manga fan in the entire Nantucket series is a deranged sadist who tortures people for the heck of it! Oh, and she's also a cannibal who literally eats babies, that's bad too, I guess.

Walker and Wong are in the process of formalizing and codifying the Achaean religion. Specifically, that Wong is the avatar of the Lady of Pain, and that Walker is King of Men. Hekate gets an undeserved bad reputation, as do many of the underworld deities from Greek Mythology. She was the goddess of witchcraft and guardian of the crossroads, and she had connections to the underworld, but she was not evil. However, thanks to Wong's cult, interpreting Hekate as an evil goddess might have some historical basis in the mixed-up world Nantucket has found itself in. Well, at least she did pick Hades as her patron deity. Hades is another god who gets unfairly pained as evil. He was firm but fair, and honestly one of the nicer gods. Be thankful for small mercies, I suppose.

Wong and Walker are also attempting to build temples and establish a formal priesthood. The Mycenaeans worshipped more or less the same gods that the Classical Greeks did. Many historians theorize that the Greek gods started out as local deities and cults before being incorporated into a single pantheon. The Mycenaeans worshipped their gods using hillside shrines, but didn't have much in the way of temples, as far as we know. It does make sense that Walker and Wong would be using religion to cement their position with Achaean society. I'm reminded of the words of the physicist Peter Weinberg. Good people will do go things, and evil people will do evil things, without any external influences. But to get good people to do evil things it takes religion, or something very much like religion. Religion has also historically been very good at enforcing conformity and the preexisting social order.

In other developments, we meet John Martins. He's a hippie, but was kidnapped by Walker and taken to Greece. Like most hippies, Martin is really into Lord of the Rings. In fact, he named his settlement Rivendell, and has commissioned several carvings and other works of art inspired by Lord of the Rings. Martins buys slaves...so that he can free them, and give them a new life in Rivendell, where they will be safe from Walker. In fact, he makes a point of always throwing a big party to welcome the newly freed slaves. Martins pretended to go along with Walker so that he could oppose and subvert him from within. He knows that Walker thinks he's just a dumb hippie, and as such, won't pay too close attention to him.

We also meet Helmut Mittler. He's a former Stasi officer, and is Walker's head of security, as well as head of the secret police. Mittler makes a point of contrast lay keeping the Achaeans in a constant state of fear and paranoia. He also makes a few choice remarks to Ian that suggest he might also be an antisemite. Well, I'm just saying, Mittler does rhyme with Hitler. And his name would probably be written on official forms as H. Mittler. Not much more to say here, but Mittler will become important in the spoilers section.

Let's circle back and talk about Ohotolarix. He is an Iraniina chief who followed Walker to Achaea. He's fiercely loyal to Walker, but he still longs for Alba. Ohotolarix finds the weather in Achaea a bit too warm for his liking, longs for the plants of his former homeland, and thinks that the Achaeans put too much garlic in their food. Naturally, Ohotolarix is elated when Walker assigns him to a fort the Achaeans have established in what is today the nation of Hungry. The climate is very similar to Alba, and he gets to laugh at Achaean troops dealing with the cold weather.

The fort has been established as part of Walker's plan to establish relations with the Ringapi people. They're a tribe from Central and Eastern Europe who, along with several other tribes, became the Sea Peoples. Who are the Sea Peoples? Short answer: nobody knows. Longer answer: we don't know, but there are several theories, usually involving the migration of different groups of peoples. Potential candidates include the Etruscans, the Philistines, and even the Mycenaeans and Minoans. I'm not familiar with any theories suggesting the Sea Peoples came from Central and Eastern Europe, but I suppose it makes as much sense as anything. Whoever they were, the Sea Peoples lead a series of coastal fading campaigns across the Eastern Mediterranean. Pharaoh Ramses II faced off against them, as did Ramses III.

The Sea Peoples are one of the factors that lead to the Bronze Age Collapse. The Bronze Age Collapse, as the name suggests, was a series of events resulting in the complete collapse of several Eastern Mediterranean and Near Eastern civilizations. Historians used to believe that the Sea Peoples were the primary cause of the Bronze Age Collapse. However, most modern historians consider the Sea Peoples to be one factor among many. Other factors include, but are not limited to, climate change, volcanic eruptions, social unrest and upheaval, and disruption of trade routes. Hmm, I suppose it is entirely conceivable that, thanks to Nantucket, the Bronze Age Collapse will never happen in this brave new world.

Also, something I just thought of, where are the Minoans? The Minoans were still around at the time the series takes place, but they're nowhere to be seen. Isketerol briefly mentions them we he sees flushing toilets on Nantucket back in Island in the Sea of Time. He says he's only ever known the Minoans to have such things. That actually does have basis in reality. Archeologists have discovered evidence suggesting that the Minoans did indeed have flushable toilets. However, we never get any other mention of the Minoans beyond this. Of course, knowing Walker, he probably conquered and enslaved them.

In other returning characters, George MacAndrews finally got his wish to go to Egypt. He discovered that the Ancient Egyptians are a lot of things, but Black isn't one of them. In fact, he frequently gets made fun of due to his dark skin. MacAndrews even remarks that Ramses II, also known as Ramses the Great, looks like an Italian guy he knew who owned a pizza joint in Nashville. Genetic analysis of mummies suggest that the Ancient Egyptians weren't too different from modern day Egyptians in terms of race and ethnicity. In fact, we know that Ramses himself had red hair. Egypt sits at the crossroads of three continents, and probably had a mix of peoples. Black people weren't unheard of, but certainly weren't the majority. Most Ancient Egyptians probably looked like the other peoples of the Middle East.

MacAndrews tried to implement the Latin Alphabet, but the scribes put up too much resistance. I suppose this does make since. Walker was able to implement the Latin Alphabet in Achaea because, prior to that, they'd been using the Minoan writing system, which wasn't suited to their language. Egypt, by contrast, was doing just fine with hieroglyphics, and the scribes were more entrenched into society. Hmm, I guess the Greek Alphabet will never be invented in this new timeline.

MacAndrews also discovered that Ramses the Great was really more like Ramses the So-So. Turns out, Ramses had a bit of a tendency to fudge the details on the official records of his battles and conquests. This is fairly true to real life. Egyptian rulers did indeed have a tendency to be less than honest about their achievements. To be fair, so did the rulers of most pre-modern societies. In particular, the record speaks of the glories of Ramses campaign against the Hittites. However, Ramses himself admits he was far less successful than the record says.

This is indeed true to life. For example, Egyptian accounts of the Battle of Kadesh claim that it was a victory for Egypt, despite Ramses failing to take the city. However, Hittite accounts claim that the Egyptians retreated in shameful defeat. Most historians agree that the battle was probably a draw, but a slight tactical victory for Egypt. Incidentally, the Battle of Kadesh lead to the Egyptians and Hittites signing to oldest known peace treaty in World History. In fact, a copy of the Treaty of Kadesh hangs in the United Nations headquarters in New York City. The Egyptians and Hittites frequently got into border skirmishes in the Levent, but they had begrudging respect for one another, and considered each other to be worthy opponents.

As for Ramses II himself, he was certainly no slouch when it came to warfare, but his primary claim to fame is his talent as a statesman. He was also known for his religion devotion, and the many temples he built, such as the temples of Abu Simbel and the hypostyle hall at the Temple of Karnak. One minor complaint I had about On the Oceans of Eternity was that I wished we'd gotten more scenes set in Egypt.

Nantucket continues to do well for itself amidst the war effort. They've even begun to establish colonies and homesteads on mainland New England and even Long Island. However, these homesteads tend to have a fairly high failure rate. Farming isn't as easy as it looks, especially when you're a bit low on modern equipment. Still, at last they finally have coffee thanks to the coffee plants that were on Nantucket during the Event. Unfortunately, decorative coffee plants are bred for their looks, not their taste. As such, the coffee tastes horrible, but caffeine is caffeine, I guess. The Ethiopian Highlands were much the only place with coffee plants during the Bronze Age, and it might be a while before Nantucket can send an expedition to them.

Speaking of expeditions, Nantucket has sent an expedition to explore the interior of North America. I found these sections to be the weakest part of On the Oceans of Eternity. They weren't bad per se, the writing was certainly good enough to keep me reasonably entertained. However, they star a group of characters that we didn't meet until this book, so I feel less of a connection to them. Also, out of all the place they could have gone, why the wilderness of North America? There were still plenty of other Bronze Age civilizations left to explore. Shang Dynasty China, the various Andes cultures, Jomon era Japan, and the Indus Valley Civilizations, just to name a few. Archeological evidence suggest that Scandinavia had a very danced Bronze Age culture equal to that of Greece. Hey, there's another potential destination. It was even briefly mentioned that Nantucket had made contact with the Andes civilizations, and had established trade relations with Shang Dynasty China. Shang pirates even briefly appeared in Against the Tide of Years.

Well, there might have been a reason why those civilizations were left out, but we'll discuss that towards the end of the review. I will say that things finally picked up when the expedition reached California and discovered that Tartessos had secretly established a colony. So, I guess not a total bust on that regard. Also, random aside, whenever anyone mentioned Martha's Vineyard, I had to remember that it is a real place in Massachusetts. Having a character named Martha created a bit of a who's on first situation.

I’ll also take one final moment to plug the audiobook version. Todd McLaren is talented as hell, and really was the only person who could do this series justice. 

Okay, now we're getting into the really big spoilers. So, if you don't want any of that, turn back now.

Last chance, sure you want to continue?

Well, okay. If everyone who wants out is gone, let's get into it.

So, what does the Nantucket military discover when they arrive in Tartessos? They find...that Isketerol has genuinely improved things for the common people. He had implemented the Latin Alphabet, and is working to increase literacy rates. He's had trees planted along the roads and streets to provide natural shade. Isketerol has also implemented programs to educate and train the people of Tartessos in the new knowledge and technology Nantucket has. Isketerol said that he wanted to improve Tartessos, prevent it from being just a footnote in the history books, and he meant that. The conflict between Nantucket and Tartessos is resolved with surprisingly little bloodshed, but I guess that makes sense. Tartessos was humbled in Against the Tide of Years when it tried to invade Nantucket, and promptly got its ass kicked. Plus, the alliance with Walker was more of an alliance of convenience than anything.

Of course, for all its many advantages, Nantucket still has a serious manpower shortage. That's been a big theme across the series. For example, they manage to liberate Sicily, but it's up in the air as to whether Nantucket will be able to keep things peaceful and stable after the war is over. Walker's biggest advantage is the sheer number of troops he has at his disposal.

Odikweos has been using Ian to learn more about where Walker comes from. Ian, in turn, recognizes Odikweos as the historical figure who inspired the legend of Odysseus. He even reads to Odikweos from The Odyssey. Odikweos already really didn't like Walker, but now he's seriously pissed that Walker robbed him of his future glory. Unfortunately, he's still bound to Walker's service, and thus can't kill him. If he did, he'd be committing a major taboo of Achaean society.

The resolution was...well, I gotta admit, I did not see it coming. Walker, Wong, and most of their followers go on a boar hunt and then have a feast. Everyone is having a good time, and then they all drop dead. Turns out, Mittler poisoned the barbecue sauce used for the feast. Walker's favorite barbecue sauce contains lots of chilies, which disguised the poison Mittler used. Mittler has been planning on stabbing Walker in the back for quite some time. Now, all Odikweos has to do is kill Mittler, and he'll have avenged Walker. On doing so, Odikweos is freed from his service to Walker, and can claim the throne of Achaea for himself.

Like I said, I really didn't see that coming, but I liked it. It has been established that most of Walker's "allies" are constantly scheming and plotting to undermine him in various ways. MacAndrews and Martins both took advantage of the fact that Walker viewed them as little more than useful idiots. So, I suppose it is a fitting end for William Walker and Alice Wong.

Speaking of MacAndrews, Nantucket has defeat Egypt in a battle near the city of Megiddo, which is also known by its Greek name Armageddon. Fittingly enough, the battle is known as the Battle of Armageddon. MacAndrews decides that it is time to get out of dodge. He decides that, since there are no preexisting ancient black empires, he'll just have to make one of his own. He's heading south to Meroe, and plans to establish his kingdom in Sudan. 

In our world, there was an empire named Kush which arose in the Nubia region, near what is now Sudan. Kush even briefly conquered Egypt during the 25th Dynasty. And yes, Kush was indeed an ancient black empire, just like MacAndrews dreamed of. Of course, Nantucket arrived about 200 years before the founding of Kush. I guess MacAndrews is trying to speed-up history. Stirling has said that MacAndrews’ kingdom would have played a major role in the sequels that never materialized. He says the capital would be located near what is Khartoum in our world. A good place for capital city; lots of iron and plenty of land that can easily be irrigated.  

Meanwhile, Althea Walker happened to be away when everyone got poisoned. She decides to do some empire building of her own. She and Ohotolarix head to Central Asia. Althea hopes that being so far from the sea will allow her empire to grow without having to worry about Nantucket.

Also, on a more minor note, Nantucket doctor Justin Clemens married his Babylonian assistant Azzu-ena. He uses the caduceus as his symbol on the Babylonian marriage document. The caduceus frequently gets mistaken for the Rod of Asclepius, and is erroneously used as symbol for the medical profession, especially in America. The caduceus was the symbol of the Greek god Hermes; he was the god of many things, but medicine and healing were not among them. Asclepius was the Greek god of healing. For reference, the caduceus is a rod with two intertwined snakes and wings at the top. The Rod of Asclepius, by contrast, is a stick with a single servant coiled around it, and lacks wings. The caduceus has also been used as a symbol of commerce. A far more fitting use, given that Hermes was god of merchants.

Of course, because of Justin, there might be some historical basis for the caduceus as a symbol of medic in the new timeline. Nantucket is probably going to make future archeologists of this new timeline scratch their heads with all the anachronisms they cause. That'll be especially true is Nantucket's decedent a forget that their ancestors came from the future. Well, the future of another timeline, but details. Ian even remarks that future historians are probably going to come up with all sorts of crazy explanations for how Nantucket pulled-off everything it did.

So, the series ends with Nantucket having Christmas party, with the leaders of their allies in attendance. Kashtiliash himself pays Nantucket a visit, and he is joined by Odikweos and even Isketerol. So, I guess that means that Nantucket and Tartessos are putting the past behind them. There is a festive mood in the air as the characters toast to the future of their crazy mixed-up new world. Maybe it isn't quite the best of all possible worlds, but they're working on it.

Obviously, there are a lot of sequel hooks here. We've got Althea and MacAndrews attempting to build their own empires. We've also got a Nantucket airship crew who have crashed in Central Asia and are trying to make their way home. And there's just the general potential of what this world will look like in the future. Perhaps that's why Shang Dynasty China and the Indus Valley Civilizations were ignored. Althea building her empire in Central Asia would serve as a good springboard for incorporating China and India into the series. I still maintain that the Iraniina becoming zealous converts to Christianity would come back to bite Nantucket in the ass at some point.

All of that being said, I still feel that On the Oceans of Eternity does a good job wrapping up the trilogy. Most of the major plot threads are tied up, but it also leaves open the possibility for more adventures. Overall, I was very satisfied with how On the Oceans of Eternity ended. 

So, there was definitely potential for a sequel series, but it never materialized. Following the Island in the Sea of Time series, Stirling wrote the first trilogy of the Emberverse series. It covers the world that Nantucket left behind. More specifically, the laws of physics change so that electricity, gunpowder, explosives, internal combustion, and steam-power no longer work. It's a tad more complicated than that, but that's the non-spoiler version of what happened. The Emberverse gets its name from Dies the Fire, the first book of the series. Personally, given the choice, I'll take Nantucket. I can't live in a world without air conditioning. Not sure what the air conditioning situation is with Nantucket, but at least electricity still works, so they could have it. 

They make for an interesting contrast. Island in the Sea of Time is about the technological present entering the mythical past. Emberverse, by contrast, is about the mythical past entering the technological present. The two series are mirror images of each other. 

The Emberverse was a mass success in terms of sales, so that is where Stirling focused his writing energies. As Stirling himself says, his publisher is the one who decides which of his books get sequels. Stirling has written a couple of short stories set in the world of Island in the Sea of Time. One is a novella that covers the Battle of Armageddon in more detail. It is called “Ridding Shotgun to Armageddon” and is collected in an anthology of Stirling’s short stories called Ice, Iron, and Gold. The other takes place twenty years after the events of On the Oceans of Eternity. It is called “Blood Wolf” and was collected in the anthology The First Heroes: New Tales of the Bronze Age edited by Harry Turtledove and Noreen Doyle.

It is certainly a bit sad that we never got more books in the Island in the Sea of Time series. Still, it's better than what happened with The Peshawar Lancers, which sadly remains a standalone book. And hey, we got three amazing books out of the Island in the Sea of Time series. Each of them was even better than its predecessor. For that alone, we should be thankful for all of Stirling's creativity and hard work.

Perhaps one day I will be able to visit the Nantucket of our world. If I use my imagination, perhaps I will be able to imagine myself on an island in the sea of time, set against the tide of years, on the oceans of eternity. I also hope I'll get to visit the Eagle too. They have visitation days, I believe. I'll have to ask the crew if they've heard of Island in the Sea of Time.

Well, that should do it from me for now. I will see you guys next time.

Book Review: Against the Tide of Years by S.M. Stirling

Well, it has taken a while, but I'm back once again with another review of S.M. Stirling's Island in the Sea of Time series. There isn't really much more to add. Well, I will say I'm glad everyone liked the first review. Even S.M. Stirling himself commented on how he enjoyed it when I shared it in the S.M. Stirling Fan Group on Facebook. Without further ado, let's jump into it. We're taking a look at Against the Tide of Years by S.M. Stirling.

A few years have passed since the events of the first book. The temporally displaced people of Nantucket are adjusting well to their new lives in the Bronze Age. Trade is flourishing and new alliances are being forged. However, a storm is brewing on the horizon. William Walker, though temporarily defeat and set back, has licked his wounds and moved on to Greece. Here, Walker and his cronies have made a second, and far more successful, attempt at empire building. The people of Nantucket know that they're going to have to defeat Walker once and for all if they want their new world to be safe. Nantucket is going to make new allies, and find new adventures, in a world set against the tide of years.

As you might recall, I absolutely loved Island in the Sea of Time, the first book in the series. Against the Tide of Years not only managed to keep up the momentum, but might be even better than Island in the Sea of Time. The first notable difference is that, this time around the major civilizations of the Bronze Age Mediterranean and Near East play major roles in the plot. Walker's segments are set in Mycenaean Greece, while Nantucket has courted the Babylonian and Hittite Empires as allies against Walker. More information has survived about these civilizations compared to Bronze Age England, Tartessos, and the Olmecs. Though, that having been said, they still have a lot of blanks spaces, and details we aren't certain about. So, Stirling has more information to work with, but still had plenty of wiggle room with how he depicted these Bronze Age civilizations.

As I've said before, with so many competing theories about life in the Bronze Age, there is no way Stirling could be faithful to them all. Having said that, it is still very impressive how closely he follows many of these theories, and the attention to detail with his depiction of the Bronze Age cultures and civilizations.

Okay, so let's start in Babylon. Tartessos is allied with Walker, and they're center in Southern Spain, and have expanded into North Africa. So, sailing through the Straights of Gibraltar is not an option for Nantucket. As such, they must sail around the Cape of Good Hope, and then sail back up to Babylon. They plan to go up through Babylon, and then use Anatolia as a jumping-off point for their assault on Walker's empire in Greece. Nantucket learn how to speak Akkadian, the primary language used in Babylon, from a date merchant they found in Persia named Shamash, known as Sham for short. They took measures to be damn sure he wouldn't stab them in the back and betray them like Isketerol did.

At the start of the story, the King of Babylon is Shagarakti-Shuriadh, a member of the Kassite Dynasty. He was a real king who ruled Babylon around the time of Against the Tide of Years. Though, not very much is known about him, as is often the case with Bronze Age Mesopotamia. Shagarakti welcomes the Nantucketers with open-arms, and is more than happy to accept the many gifts and innovations that Nantucket brings to Babylon. He especially enjoyed the ride he got in a hot air balloon. There's a really interesting scene where he discusses the history of Babylon and says something to the effect of "We are an ancient land. We go back long ago to the days of Hammurabi and his law code, and further still to the days of Sargon the Great and Gilgamesh. Though that's only if you believe the old legends."

It would seem that the Babylonians are well aware that some of their legends might not have basis now reality. This goes back to a major theme of the series: people of the past were not stupid. They didn't have access to the same knowledge that modern day people do, but they had the same hardware as we do. They were ignorant, not stupid.

Shagarakti recognizes that the Nantucketers are very knowledgeable, not to mentioned quite technologically advanced, and defers to them on most matters without issue. There is a scene where he becomes a bit sad when he realizes how primitive Babylon must seem to Nantucket. However, he is assured that the civilization Nantucket comes from was only made possible thanks to the ground work laid by earlier civilizations, such as Babylon. If Nantucket sees further, it is only because they stand on the shoulders of giants like Babylon.

The most pressing concern on the Babylonian front, besides Walker, is that Assyria is due to conquer Babylon soon. Obviously, Nantucket can't have this happen if they want Babylon to be their ally against Walker. That brings us to Kashtiliash. He is, at the start of the book, the Crown Prince of Babylon, and was also a real person. In our world, he led an unsuccessful campaign against the Assyrians, which not only resulted in his death, but also lead to Assyria invading Babylon. Thanks to Nantucket, Kashtiliash survives the campaign and decisively defeats the Assyrians. Though, Nantucket does convince Babylon to keep Assyria as a nominally independent client state; that taxing Assyria is preferable to outright annexing them.

It is during the campaign that meets Kathryn Hollard. She serves in the Nantucket military alongside her brother Kenneth, who is a general. She's an extremely skilled fighter and a competent solider, as is to be expect of someone in the Nantucket Armed Forces. She keeps her hair extremely short, as is required for the Nantucket Army. Apparently, the Coast Guard has laxer standard when it comes to haircare, as Swindapa is mentioned wearing her hair in a braid a few times. Anyway, Kashtiliash couldn't care less, and thinks that Kathryn is the most amazing woman he's ever met. He relishes the opportunity to get to fighter at her side, and back-to-back, during the campaign against Assyria. She too becomes interested in him, and eventually they decide to get married.

This does make Kenneth a little worried. He rightfully points out that, though the Babylonians were better than their Islamic descendants, they still hold many less than enlightened attitudes. Thankfully, Kashtiliash is both open-minded and a true gentleman. This also makes it easier for Nantucket to plant the seeds of modernity within Babylon, and nudge Kashtiliash towards reform. Like most Bronze Age civilizations, Babylon still practices slavery, and Shagarakti gifts 200 slaves to the Nantucket delegation. The Nantucketers immediately free the slaves, and assign them to work at the hospital of Nantucket's military base in Mesopotamia. Hey, most Nantucket Coast Guard ships are named after famous abolitionist and Union general from the American Civil War. There's no way Nantucket is going to take part in slavery.

The former slaves are taught how to read and write, and about modern medical practices. Shagarakti and Kashtiliash are baffled as to way Nantucket would free so many slaves like that. Nantucket does want to end slavery, but at the moment, stopping Walker is their number one goal. They certainly wouldn't be able to free any slaves is Walker wins. One aspect of the medical reforms I found interesting was the importance of sanitation and disposal. Flies like to eat poo, and they also have a tendency to land on food that people eat. So, the germs from the poo get on the food, and people who eat the food get sick. Proper sanitation is also important is you want to avoid cholera and typhoid.

Okay, so how have things been going back on Nantucket? The Islanders have been adjusting quite well to their new home. The Coast Guard has led several expedition to far flung quarters of the world. They're really more of a navy at this point, but Alston and her crew would never dream of serving in a navy. The various branches of the American military have a bit of a rivalry. Moas are being farmed on Nantucket following a Coast Guard expedition to New Zealand. The closest living relative of the moa is a South American bird called the tinamous. They're quite tasty; in fact, they've been over hunted because of how tasty they are. So, it stands to reason that moa were also quite tasty. Moa were also one of the largest birds to ever exists; so, plenty of meat per bird.

Nantucket has also established Coast Guard bases across the world. For example, Ur Base is Nantucket's main base in Mesopotamia, and they have a base on the Cape of Good Hope named Mandela Base. There is an especially funny scene where Alston goes to inspect a base in Mauritius. For reference, they're islands off the coast of Madagascar, and famous for being home of the dodo. The man in charge of the base has been shirking his duties and subcontracting them to the Alban workers under his command. He's also allowed the animals around the base to breed unchecked. This prompts Alston to say "This is an island. It is a tropical island. BUT IT'S NOT GILLIGAN'S ISLAND! DO YOU HEAR ME, MISTER?!" It's made even more funny when Swindapa asks Ian Arnstein who this Gilligan person is.

Alston and Swindapa having been doing fairly themselves. They've adopted a pair of war orphans from Alba. Lucy and Heather company their mothers on Coast Guard mission around the world, and constantly get into mischief. Lucy in particular is notable due to who her biological parents are. Her mother was an Alban woman, but her father is George MacAndrews. He's one of Walker's cronies. MacAndrews felt that Nantucket wasn't doing enough to help African people resist colonialism. He was also concerned that Black culture on Nantucket will die out within a few generations. The total number Black people on Nantucket at the time of The Event was less than 200. Alston also had some trepidation about this, but unlike MacAndrews, she made her peace with it and learned to accept it.

We'll get into this more in the next book, but one of the things I liked about MacAndrews is that he's not stupid. He's wrongheaded about several things, not to mentions more than a bit ignorant about history, but he isn't stupid. He's fully aware that Walker isn't his friend, and he knows full well that Walker is a colonizer. However, he biding his time in hopes that Walker will send him to Egypt. Walker considers Egypt to be a potential threat to his new empire, and wants to bring them into his sphere of influence. MacAndrews hopes to be Walker's ambassador to Egypt, and then use it as an opportunity to introduce modern technology to Egypt.

I should mention that MacAndrews is one of those Afrocentrists who believes that Ancient Egypt to have been a Black civilization. In reality, however, the Ancient Egyptians were most likely Semitic people not too dissimilar to other Middle Eastern people. Genetic analysis of mummies does bear this out, and suggest Ancient Egyptians weren't too dissimilar to Modern Egyptians in terms of ethnicity. Ramses the Great had red hair and light skin; we know this thanks to his mummy. Ancient Egypt was briefly ruled by a Nubian dynasty, but this was only for short amount of time. In fact, at one point an envoy from Egypt arrives to visit Walker in Greece. He has skin the color of light toast, which clearly doesn't sit well with MacAndrews. Despite this, he remains optimistic that the envoy is simply an outlier. However, come the next book, MacAndrew will learn that denial isn't just a river in Egypt.

Despite his Afrocentrist views, MacAndrews clearly wasn't above having sex with white women. It seems that MacAndrews is unaware of Lucy's existence. Of course, he doesn't seem terribly concerned about the possibility that there might have any little MacAndrews running around somewhere. Still, could have been potentially interesting had he ever found out, especially if he learn who Lucy's adoptive mothers are. Lucy being mixed race does occasionally earn surprised looks from the Bronze Age peoples. Hey, Nantucket's technology boarders on magical to the people of the Bronze Age. For all they know, Nantucket could have found a way for two women to have a child together. This obviously isn't the case, but it makes for some amusing scenes.

Swindapa is adjusting well to life on Nantucket. Sometimes she does cartwheels down the street just for the heck of it. Though, when she takes a trip back to Alba, she finds that she feels disconnected from the other Earth Folk. It isn't just how much things have changed in Alba over the last few years. Nantucket is Swindapa's home now, and it has become a part of her. She's not the only Alban on Nantucket. Plenty of other Albans, Earth Folk and Iraiina, have immigrated to Nantucket over the years. The Earth Folk are still loyal worshippers of Moon Woman. The Iraiina, however, have become rather zealous converts to Christianity. This occasionally results in odd things, such as Iraiinas swearing pagan-style oaths in the name of Jesus and Mary.

Ian and Doreen Arnstein are doing quite well. They're acting as Nantucket's ambassadors to the Babylonian Empire. They've got a son named David, and have another child on the way. At the start of Against the Tide of Years, we get an excerpt from a history book written several decades after the events of the series. From this, we see that David will follow in Ian's footsteps and became a historian. There is a scene where Ian considers that, for all the chaos it caused, were it not for The Event, he would have never met Doreen, and David would never have been born.

Doreen jokes that, if not for Ian, her only options would be to try her luck with Moses. Ramses II, also known as Ramses the Great, is one of the candidates for having for having been the pharaoh of the biblical exodus. However, generally speaking biblical archeologists consider Ramses the least likely candidate to having been the exodus pharaoh. The reasons Ramses is associated as such is because he was portrayed as the exodus pharaoh in the Cecil B. DeMille movie The Ten Commandments. The Prince of Egypt, which took quite a few cues from The Ten Commandments, further reinforced this notion within the public consciousness. However, it should be noted that there is no archeological evidence that Ancient Hebrews ever lived in Egypt, or than anyone named Moses ever existed.

You could argue that it wasn't Stirling asserting this, but rather, Doreen and Ian stating their own, potentially incorrect, views. On the topic of religion, Nantucket has experienced something of a religious revival. However, it is in a quiet personal sort of way. All of the major Christian denominations have united into a single church lead by Father Gomez, who is now known as Prelate Gomez. The book makes a good case for how this happened, but you'd think at least a few denominations would put up resistance to amalgamation.

Rounding out the returning main cast, Jared and Martha are busy keeping Nantucket's government running, but are doing well. They've also adopted some war orphans from Alba, but also have kids via the conventional way. Nantucket ran out of birth control and condoms fairly quickly following The Event. At one point, Jared muses how it is entirely possible that his adopted kids were his ancestors in the original timeline. It just goes to show what a mixed-up world Nantucket has found itself in. Jared is prioritizing a new set of laws to help protect the environment. The Bronze Age world is full of natural wonders, and Jared wants to make sure they're preserved for future generations. Of course, that assume that future generations will actually stick to the laws, and not screw things up. Still, it is step in the right direction, and I suppose it is the thought that counts.

Okay, all well and good, but what has Walker been up to? He's relocated to Mycenaean Greece for a second attempt at empire building. Walker believes he failed in England because the Iraiina were still, technologically speaking, in the Stone Age. That, and England is close to Nantucket, relatively speaking. Greece already has the foundation of Bronze Age technology, and it is far away from Nantucket. Plus, he has Tartessos to help keep Nantucket at bay. Walker has created a new capital named Walkeropolis. Pretty much all of Greece, known as Greater Achaea, is firmly under his control. Greater Achaea recently conquered Sicily, and subjugated the native population.

Some historian believe that the characters of The Iliad may have been real people. Or, at the very least, they were inspired by real people. Obviously, if you subscribe to this version, then characters like Achilles and Aeneas weren't actually demigods. Stirling decides to assume that at least some of the characters of The Iliad were real people. It makes for a more entertaining story, and I do love a bit of Greek Mythology. For example, upon arriving in Mycenae, Walker quickly worms his way into the good graces of Agamemnon. Several years later, Agamemnon has come to seriously regret allying with Walker.

During the events of the story, a king from Ithaca named Odikweos comes to visit Agamemnon. He is a cunning and intelligent man, as well as a devote of the goddess Athena. The implication is that Odikweos inspired the legend of Odysseus. Odikweos quickly surmises that Walker is not to be trusted, but he's also aware that he has to bide his time, at least for now. I always viewed the Mycenaeans and Minoans as just the pre-show warm-up act to the main event of Classical Greece. Against the Tide of Years, as well as On the Oceans of Eternity, showed me that there was plenty of fun to be had during the Mycenaean era. In fact, I actually went on a bit of a Mycenaean, and Bronze Age in general, kick after I completed Nantucket trilogy. I guess that another testament to Stirling's talent as a writer.

Walker has implemented some reforms that were genuinely beneficial to the Mycenaeans. Albeit, he did so for pragmatic reasons. For example, he introduces the Latin Alphabet to Greece. Prior to that, the Mycenaean had been using the Minoan Alphabet, which isn't really suited to their language. The scribes initially objected, on the grounds that the Latin Alphabet is so simple even a child could learn it. Obviously, this is precisely why Walker wants to use it. Walker has also introduced new foods, such as tomatoes, to Greece. He's also introduced modern horse breeds; who are strong, faster and larger than Bronze Age horses. Said modern horses were ones he stole from Nantucket.

On the flip side, much of the countryside around Mycenae is an industrial hellscape due to the many factories Walker had built. Oh, and he reshaped the Mycenaean economy so that slavery forms its backbone. The Mycenaeans practiced slavery, as did most Bronze Age civilizations, but not anywhere near to the heights Walker brings it. More importantly, this makes it so that the Mycenaean economy will collapse unless Walker is around to keep things running. Walker is cruel and sadistic, but there is a certain logic to what he does. A twisted sort of logic, but one that is easy to follow and understand. It is part of what makes Walker such a compelling villain.

The same, however, can't be said of Walker's wife, Alice Wong. I should clarify that she's his favorite wife; Walker is also married to several Mycenaean women. Alice Wong used to be a doctor before The Event. As such, she knows all the best places to torture people for the most pain. Unlike Walker, she doesn't have any greater scheme with her sadism. Wong appears to be evil just for the sake of being evil. There's a scene where Walker walks in on Wong torturing a Mycenaean princess, and it's almost comical how blasé they both are about it. In fact, several of the scenes set at Mycenae have an almost sitcom feel to them. Well, if you ignore the fact that the dad is a megalomaniac with plans of world domination, and that the mom is a sadistic torture technician.

Walker has a daughter named Althea, who is well on her way to following in her father's footsteps. Interestingly, Althea's mother is not Wong, but rather, Ohotolarix’s daughter. Ohotolarix is an Iraiina chief who followed Walker to Greece. We’ll talk more about him when we get to On the Oceans of Eternity.

Against the Tide of Years ends with Walker's army arriving at the gates of Troy. Nantucket wanted to use Troy as a jumping-off point for the invasion of Greater Achaea. There's a scene where Ian Arnstein, from atop the walls of Troy, says to Walker "Your mother was a hamster, and your father smelt of elder berries." Walker cracks a smile and admits that he found that genuinely amusing. He found it amusing, but he's still going to sack Troy.

Troy is depicted as being mostly Hittite, but with some slight Mycenaean influences. This is what most historians believe that the historical Troy would have been like. Troy has been continually inhabited for thousands of years. As such, there are many archeological layers to the city. Many of these layers show clear signs of warfare. Historians and archeologists are still not entirely certain which layer was the one Homer was talking about in The Iliad. However, the date that Stirling gives is a popular estimation among historians.

Well, I'd better wrap things up before this review goes on for too long. Once again, Todd McLaren does an excellent job with the audiobook. The only point of criticism I have is that he gave Alice Long a slight Asian accent, despite there being no indication that she speaks with any discernible accent. Other than that, great work as usual. Also, I just love the image on the cover of the Babylonian charioteer with an American flag on the back of his chariot. It really gives a feel for what kind of series Island in the Sea of Time is.

Well, I think that should do it from me for now. I will see you guys next time.

Book Review: Island in the Sea of Time by S.M. Stirling

Sometimes, I will listen to an audiobook, absolutely love it, and I will know it is a book I have to review. That way, I can share it with other people. Of course, sometimes life gets in the way, or I have to put it off for other reasons. But, sooner or later, I usually get around to it. That brings us to the book we'll be reviewing today. We're taking a look at Island in the Sea of Time by S.M. Stirling.

Island in the Sea of Time begins on 1998 AD on the island of Nantucket. It's a sleepy little island off the coast of Massachusetts, but also a popular tourist destination. Everyone is looking forward to what the new year will bring. Then, without warning, the sky is completely filled with a strange red light. The people of Nantucket notice some strange things once the sky returns to normal. The cities on the mainland have been replaced by unbroken forest, there are no radio signals, and the stars in the are totally different. Before long everyone reaches a startling conclusion: they've been sent back in time to the Bronze Age. Specifically, they're now in the year 1250 BC.

Like it or not, the people of Nantucket are going to change the past no matter what they do. Will they choose to create a better world; one free from the mistakes of the old? Or will a hostile flag of conquest fly across the Bronze Age world?

I'd known about this book for a while. It's kind of hard not to if you're into alternate history. The online alternate history has its own slang and acronyms for various tropes. One of these is named ISOT, which, of course, is short for Island in the Sea of Time. It refers to any land or individuals, from as small as a single person to as large as a whole country, getting transported to a different time, usually somewhere in the past. You then try to imagine what happens from there, much as this book series does.

I'm glad I finally got around to checking this series out. It was as excellent as I thought it would be, and it quite well researched as well. Obviously, with all the competing theorizes about life in the Bronze Age, there's no way that Stirling could possibly be faithful to them all. That having been said, the ones that he does decide to go with are extremely well researched. Moreover, Stirling had to, in essence, create many of the cultures feature in this series completely out of whole cloth. This is by necessity due to lack of surviving written records. For example, we know that Tartessos probably existed, that it was located in Southern Spain, and some people think it inspired Plato's account of Atlantis...and that's pretty much it. Stirling had to create basically everything about Tartessos and its culture from scratch. Oh, but don't worry, he succeeded with flying colors.

I briefly became obsessed with all thing Bronze Age after reading the Island in the Sea of Time trilogy. I fully blame that on Stirling excellent writing skills. I also wish to visit Nantucket someday. Many of the places mentioned in the series are indeed real places that you can visit. Stirling has posted pictures of several trips he took to Nantucket on Facebook, and it looks absolutely gorgeous. Nantucket has some of the best preserved pre-Civil War architecture in America.

A brief side note on terminology. The series as a whole is often referred to as Island in the Sea of Time, after the first book. This is how I prefer to refer to it. However, you will sometimes see it referred to as the Nantucket trilogy or the Islander trilogy. Just thought I should let you know. 

A significant chunk of the novel is dedicated to the Islanders working to make Nantucket self-sufficient and laying the foundations of their new nation. I was worried that this might drag on too long, and we wouldn't get very much alternate history goodness. Fortunately, I'm pleased to report that this is not the case. In fact, I found these segments to be quite engrossing and entertaining. I suppose that is a testament to Stirling's talent as a writer.

I also liked that there was conflict some conflict, of varying scale, because not everyone was on-board with the new state of affairs. There's one scene where an accountant flips-out because he's been assigned to help clear land for farm plots. He rails at how unfair it is that he's being force to perform manual labor. It's understandable why he'd feel that way; I'd probably feel similar. Still, Nantucket needs manpower and laborers, not accountants. Especially since they're also having to rebuild the economy from scratch. At this point, they're using work chits as a currency of sorts. Basically, you work a job for a set among of time, and get a certain number of chits to spend on whatever you wish. Money from the old universe is considered worthless. It is a basic economic truth that money has no intrinsic value beyond that which we imbue upon it. Of course, after a year or so, once things get settled, Nantucket transitions to an actual official currency of its own.

I also liked how the characters have to deal with the loss of stupid incidental stuff you probably wouldn't think about. You have various characters think on how much they'd give for something as simple as hamburger or a club sandwich. The loss of coffee is another big blow to everyone's collective moral. Sure, there are some coffee plants on the island, but they're bred to look pretty, not for their flavor. Wild coffee plants were mostly confined to the Ethiopian highlands in 1250 BC. For me, I think the biggest blow would be the loss of seamless socks. I have very sensitive skin, and socks with seams drive me completely insane. The lack, or least rationing, of air conditioning would also be a major downer. Not having any tea would also be unfortunate.

It's also mentioned that Internet addicts are taking it rough, but at least they're getting involved in community theatre and music groups. This book was written in 1998, when the Internet was still in its infancy. If the book had been written today, pretty much everyone on Nantucket would be dealing with major Internet withdrawal. Think about it; streaming services, YouTube, online video games, all the various information websites, Amazon, and search engines all just went poof. Oh, and your favorite review blog, by which I mean this one, would also be gone. Social media would also be gone, but that might not be such a bad thing...I say despite how much I use it to promote this blog. Relatedly, it's mentioned that of the teachers on the island took to living together; because living alone gets lonely when you don't have entertainment at your fingertips.

Now I think we should discuss the characters. I should mention that it wasn't just Nantucket that was sent back in time, but also the surrounding waters. This is important because the Eagle, and her crew, came along for the ride. It's a Coast Guard training ship that is made out of metal, but also uses sails. It has engines and motors, but it is capable of running purely on sail power. It was originally built by Nazi Germany, but was capture by America during World War II and converted into a Coast Guard ship. Oh, and did I mention that the Eagle is a real ship that actually exists? The crew are all fictional, but the ship itself is very real. In fact, I've actually heard that they keep a copy of the Island in the Sea of Time trilogy aboard the Eagle.

The Eagle is captained by Marion Alston. She's a no-nonsense woman of action and a master sailor. She had wanted to be a sailor her entire life, but the Navy didn't allow women to join. So, she joined the Coast Guard, because they actually allow women to join. She also previously trained in sword fighting with katanas, which comes in handy when she needs to train the Coast Guard in hand-to-hand combat. She one of the few prominent black people on Nantucket, but that doesn't stop her from rising to position of considerable authority within the new government of Nantucket. She's also a lesbian, but while some of the more conservative residents of Nantucket grumble about this, most people don't care, especially after all she's done for Nantucket.

One of the first things Nantucket realizes is that they need food for the winter. Corn was really only being grown by the Olmec in 1250 BC, so that rules out trading with Native Americans. So, the Eagle is sent on an expedition to England to trade for grain and livestock. At this point, the native people of England are in the process being displaced by the proto-Celtic Indo-European tribes. The ingenious people are England are known as the Fiernan Bohulugi, which roughly translates to People of the Soil, or Earth Folk. They're the ones who built Stonehenge. They don't have a written language, but they have extremely advanced knowledge of astronomy, and the movements of the stars and planets. Oh, and no written language means they have to do the calculations entirely in their heads, so they're pretty good at advanced math as well.

They're a matriarchal society, and their religion is based around the worship of a goddess named Moon Woman, who is said to be the mother of the stars. From what snippets we hear, their religion is vaguely similar to Buddhism, if a bit fatalistic at times, and is mostly peaceful.

The people attacking the Earth Folk are known as the Iraiina, which means Noble Ones, but the Earth Folk called them the Sun People, because they worship a sun god as their primary deity. In contrast to the Earth Folk, the Sun People are patriarchal, highly aggressive, and expansionist. Most of their other deities seem to be based upon various Celtic gods, which makes sense, given that the Iraiina are presented as the forerunners of the Celtic peoples.

As I've previously stated, we know basically nothing about Bronze Age England and its peoples. As such, Stirling had to invent pretty much everything about the Earth Folk and Sun People all on his own. Despite this, they both felt like fully fleshed out and vibrant cultures. In fact, on time I took a linguistics class, and we talked about the history of the English Language. The professor mentioned that we know basically nothing about the first inhabitants of England. I thought about the Earth Folk, and then I felt sad when I remembered that the Earth Folk were merely figments of SM Stirling's imagination. It is the mark of a truly great author when you feel sad that the people they invented aren't real.

Also, as I've stated, with all the competing theories about life in the Bronze Age, Island in the Sea of Time can't stay accurate forever. In fact, on Facebook, SM Stirling recently shared a link to a study suggesting the way he portrayed Bronze Age England got things backwards. However, he was not distraught by this. Quite the opposite, he was actually very excited about it, because it means we are learning more about the ancient past. That's a really good attitude to have with these sorts of things.

So, when the Eagle arrives to trade with the Sun People, Marion is gifted an enslaved Earth Folk woman named Swindapa Kurlelo. Understandably, Marion immediately grants Swindapa her freedom, and Swindapa accompanies Marion back to Nantucket. Once Swindapa adjusts to life in Nantucket she develops a romantic relationship with Marion. They couldn't be more different. Swindapa is barely nineteen, is almost always cheerful, likes to do cartwheels down the street just because, and obviously, is a white girl from Bronze Age England. Marion is stoic, in her late thirties/early forties, and is a black American woman from the modern day. Despite all of this, the two become a genuinely loving and devoted couple. An interracial, inter-temporal, lesbian couple with an age gap; they're breaking all sort of barriers.

Of course, there's a dark implication here. Swindapa's life as a prisoner of the Sun People was completely abysmal. There were times when she hoped that death would claim her and put an end to it all. The implication is, in the original timeline, this is exactly what happened. If nothing else, Nantucket can be assured that Swindapa and her people are better off because of them.

Marion is in charge of Nantucket's military, but the civic affairs run by former police chief Jared Cofflin. He likes to lead by example and out his money where his mouth is. During the early days after the Event, he took part in fishing and whaling expeditions. He's the leader of Nantucket, but he's subject to the laws like everyone else. While not opposed to using force where necessary, he tends to prefer to seek peaceful solutions for Nantucket's problems. He isn't college educated, but he isn't dumb, and can be rather thoughtful and insightful at times.

Both of these points are demonstrated during Nantucket's first major crisis. One of the pastors on the island is convinced, and convinces his parishioners, that Satan sent Nantucket back in time to prevent the birth of Jesus. As such, they try to burn everything on the island down. Thankfully, the crazed parishioners are quickly stopped, though the fire does burn down the arsenal. Many people want the arsonists hanged, but Jared suggest they instead be sent in temporary exile to the island of Inagua to collect salt. They will be watched over by Nantucket's resident priest Father Gomez, who will hopefully rehabilitate them. Cooler heads prevail, and everyone votes for Jared's proposal. He reasons, in his internal monologue, that their beliefs were wrong, because God exists outside of space and time. He also reasons that Nantucket is changing things simply by being in the past.

Interestingly, several of the other Christians on Nantucket share this thinking. They reason that God will know if/when to send Jesus to the new world Nantucket has found itself in. As such, missionary trips are organized to proselytize to the Sun People. The hope is that converting to Christianity will make them less violent. Yeah, I'm not so sure about that. Considering how much violence Christianity has inspired over the years, I can see many ways converting the Sun People could backfire. If anything, it might make them more violent, because now they can declare holy wars on the Earth Folk. Or they can justify attacking the Earth Folk by claiming them to be godless blasphemers. Still, I will say that the concept of spreading a religion before the birth of its founding is interesting from a storytelling perspective. Granted, this is never a major focus of the series, but it is still interesting.

Nantucket probably would have had a much harder time making allies in the Bronze Age if not for Ian Arnstein and Doreen Rosenthal. Ian is a professor of Classical Greek History and Culture. He is a native of California, loves puns, and was visiting Nantucket when it got transported to the Bronze Age. Sharp-eyed readers will note that he bares more than a passing resemblance to fellow alternate history writer, and good friend of S.M. Stirling, Harry Turtledove. Stirling has confirmed that this is indeed deliberate.

Doreen is an astronomer who was doing research at Nantucket's observatory. She determined that Nantucket had been sent to the Bronze Age by examining the positions of the stars. She also accompanied one of the first expeditions to the mainland. Unfortunately, she had the sniffles, and accidentally gave it to the local Native American population. The Native Americans, having no immunity to such things, were completely decimated by this common cold. This is very similar to what happened in our world when Europeans made contact with the Native Americans. I'm not sure it could have really been avoided. Still, it is rather odd that Doreen, and Nantucket in general, never seem to dwell on this for very long. Granted, they have more pressing issue at the moment, but it is odd that it doesn't even get a passing consideration later on.

Doreen and Ian joke that, being two of the limited number of Jews on Nantucket, they're the only option each other has. Of course, they do actually fall in love in get married. Hmm, we've got Marion and Swindapa, Ian and Doreen, and Jared marries town librarian Martha. Stirling sure seems to enjoy pairing up characters into odd couples that still work.

Of course, what is a series like Island in the Sea of Time without a villain? William Walker is the primary antagonist of the series. He starts off as a member of the Coast Guard, but soon develops ambitions of carving out his own empire in England. Walker is a cold, calculating sociopath. He shares his name with a 19th Century historical figure who was famous for filibustering. In those days, the term meant invading other countries and setting yourself up as dictator. Stirling has confirmed that William Walker from Island in the Sea of Time was indeed modeled on the historical William Walker. Well get into this in the later books, but if you know about the life of the historical Walker, then you can guess about how things will go for the ISOT Walker.

Walker finds several allies for his cause, including a merchant from Tartessos named Isketerol. He was part of a trading expedition that was in England when the Eagle arrived. The Tartessians are master sailors, and the best shipwrights in the Mediterranean. In fact, they actually figured out that the Earth is round by studying the way that the horizon works. Though, that particular fact is mostly known amongst ship captains and their crews. Nantucket initially hoped that they could court Tartessos as a potential trading partner using Isketerol. Once on Nantucket, however, Isketerol perused some encyclopedias at the Atheneum. It is the main library on Nantucket and is built in the style of an Ancient Greek temple. From this, Isketerol realizes that the Nantucketers really are from the future by seeing pictures of the Great Pyramid and the Gates of Mycenae in ruins.

As you can imagine, he is horrified to discover that almost no information about Tartessos survived in the future. He is determined to prevent Tartessos from meeting the same fate. He concludes that Nantucket will be the biggest threat to Tartessos, and allies with Walker to get his hands on future technology and knowledge. Though, he really only views Walker as a means to an end. Amusingly, Walker pretty much views Isketerol the same way. Hmm, so Isketerol betrayed Nantucket. His name sounds a bit like Iscariot, as in Judas Iscariot, the disciple who betrayed Jesus. Also, I think that's supposed to be Isketerol on the cover of the book.

Rounding out the main antagonists, at least for this book, is Pamela Lisketter. The term social justice warrior hadn't been invented yet when Island in the Sea of Time was written, but Lisketter fits the stereotype to a T. She is an outspoken bleeding-heart progressive, very pushy with her views, gets offended at the drop of a hat, and isn't nearly as knowledgeable as she claims. For example, when Nantucket is considering starting whaling expeditions to supplement the food supply, she objects on the grounds that whales are endangered. This ignores that fact that whales were most certainly not endangered during the Bronze Age. You can practically hear the other characters rolling their eyes. It is somewhat fitting that Nantucket returned to whaling. Whaling was Nantucket's primary industry during the 19th Century.

Lisketter also criticizes Nantucket for trading with the Sun People. This ignores how desperately Nantucket needed the food, and how they allied with the Earth Folk as soon as they understood the political situation in England better. On an unrelated note, I loved the scene where the inhabitants of Nantucket see a flock of passenger pigeons for the first time. Their flocks were truly a sight to behold back before they went extinct. And there were be also sort of other amazing animals, that were driven extinct in our world, still alive during the Bronze Age. To name just a few, there were moas in New Zealand, thylacines in Australia, quaggas in South Africa, dodos in Mauritius, and Falkland Wolves in... well, the Falkland Islands.

Lisketter and her followers decide they need to save the Olmec, lest they be subject to colonialism. They enlist help from the great humanitarian himself, William Walker. You know, that white dude who is subjecting ingenious people to his colonial rule? Really, he just need a distraction for one of his plans, and Lisketter was just the useful idiot for the job. Oh, but it gets better. Turns out the Olmec didn't want to be saved. Most of Lisketter's followers are either eaten or used as human sacrifice. I'm rather reminded of those stories of missionaries who went to islands in the South Pacific, ran afoul of local customs, and wound up as the main course for dinner.

Oh, but Lisketter got the worst punishment of all. Well, the Olmec probably considered it an honor. She had green eyes, almost the exact color of jaguar eyes. The Olmec apparently have a creation myth about a woman having sex with a jaguar, and giving birth to a god. I should mention that this appears to be Stirling's own invention, in reference to the half-man half-jaguar often featured in Olmec art. So, Lisketter is forced to reenact the myth with a live jaguar, which somehow doesn't maul her. Then, she has to do it again with the village chief, who is wearing a jaguar skin robe. Needless to say, she practically begs for the sweet release of death by the time all is said and done.

Oh, and someone in her expedition spread mumps to the Olmec. One of the side effects of mumps is sterility, so congratulations Lisketter, you just whipped out the Olmec, along with all the Mesoamerican civilizations descended from them! Though, was that all Olmec, or just that settlement? In the next book we see Olmec merchants in Nantucket, suggesting that the other Olmec settlements are doing just fine. Now, the portrayal of the Olmec fell into several stereotypes about Mesoamerican civilizations. Normally, I'd be very annoyed by that. On the other hand, seeing Lisketter's followers get ripped limb-from-limb was incredibly cathartic, not to mention absolutely hilarious. I think I'll let it slide just this once.

Okay, this review has dragged on for long than I intended, and I think we need to wrap things up. There are a few other things I could add, but I'll save them for next time. Before we go, I will say there is an audiobook version. It is narrated by Todd McLaren. He's narrated a few audiobooks for both S.M. Stirling and Harry Turtledove, and he is always excellent to have as narrator.

Well, I think we'll call it a wrap for now. Island in the Sea of Time is an excellent first novel in an amazing time travel alternate history trilogy. I can't believe I waited so long to give it a try. Don't make my mistake, read/listen today. You will be glad that you did. And don't worry, my reviews of Against the Tide of Years and On the Oceans of Eternity will be here before you know it. Think I might review 1632 by Eric Flint as a compare and contrast as well.

Well, that should do it from me for now. I will see you guys next time.

Book Review: The Peshawar Lancers by S.M. Stirling

There are plenty of books I want to listen to, but they just aren't available in audio form.  It frustrating, but it is what it is.  Sometimes, however, my patience is rewarded in a big way.  Case in point, the book we're reviewing today.  We're reviewing the alternate history novel The Peshawar Lancers by S.M. Stirling. 

The Peshawar Lancers takes place in a world where, in 1878, the Earth was bombarded by a series of asteroids.  This event would later become known as The Fall.  In addition to the chaos of the impacts, there were massive tsunamis and five years of endless of winter.  The European powers fled south to their colonies in warmer climates.  The novel takes place in the year 2025.  The climate has long since stabilized, but the world has been forever changed.  The British Empire, now known as The Angrezi Raj, is centered India and has its capital in Delhi.  They've rather thoroughly gone native and the extended exile has produced a unique Anglo-Indian hybrid culture. 

The novel follows several characters from across the Angrezi Raj, and their plots do intertwine and intersect.  First, we have Athelstan King, and his right-hand man Narayan Singh, of the Peshawar Lancers; an elite military team who guard the frontier of the Viceroyalty of India.  We also follow Athelstan's twin sister Cassandra, a highly respected astronomer who is reaching a way to prevent a second Fall.  We also follow Prince Charles and Princess Sita of the British Royal Family.  Finally, there is Yasmini, a psychic girl on the run from the sworn enemy of the Angrezi Raj, the Russian Empire.  Oh, did I mention that Russia is ruled by satanic cannibals?  

I can say without a shadow of a doubt that this novel was worth the wait.  This is one of the best alternate history novels I've read in quite some time.  S.M. Stirling has long been hailed as a master of worldbuilding, and those skills are on full display here.  The world of The Peshawar Lancers is rich, vibrant and detailed.  I could practically smell the spices on the streets of Delhi, feel the rush the wind on a soaring airship, and overall just really felt like I was going on a swashbuckling alternate history British-Indian adventure.  

Let's delve into the specifics of the worldbuilding.  The Angrezi Raj is divided into three primary parts: the viceroyalties of India, Australia and the Cape.  The Viceroyalty of India comprises India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Myanmar, Malaysia and a bit of Thailand.  It is the one we get to see the most of, and it appears to be where the Anglo-Indian hybrid culture is strongest.  It is the cultural and political heart of the empire.  Each of the viceroyalties operates its own colonies across the globe, and India is in-charge of managing the British home isles.  Oh, how the tables have turned indeed.  For extra irony, the British of the home isles closely follow Indian standards of fashion and the India's spin on English.

I suppose I should elaborate on that bit.  English has gone through a few changes since The Fall.  Several lone-words from a smattering of Indian languages have crept in.  Thus, the Angrezi are prone to say things such as "The Kunwar must fulfill his rajadharma for the good of the Angrezi Raj".  Also, the "Th" sound has been replaced by "Dee" and W has been supplanted by V.  Despite all of this, the Angrezi insist that they are speaking the exact same English as Queen Victoria I. 

The Church of England has pretty much become Hinduism in all but name; though it is mentioned a more conservative version, closer to the original thing, exists as well.  Characters frequently swear in the name of various Hindu deities.  Though it was also mentioned that Benjamin Disraeli, who lead the evacuation efforts during The Fall, has become a saint.  Perhaps in the biggest bit of irony, the Angrezi consider beef-eating to be extremely taboo, and Angrezi cuisine has fully embraced Indian ingredients.  Charles and Sita shudder at the thought that their ancestors ate cows.  There's a particularly amusing scene where Henri de Vascogne, a visiting French diplomat, is amazed at how flavorful and tasty Angrezi cuisine is; noting the old stories about British cuisine being bland must have false.  In fact, he finds Angrezi breakfast foods to be a bit over spiced for his taste. 

Most of Britain's colonies in Southern Africa, plus a few Portuguese and would-have-been German colonies, have become the Viceroyalty of the Cape.   They're pretty much Apartheid Era South Africa, but bigger and with a steampunk-lite level of technology.  There's talk of them breaking away from the Raj, but they're still loyal...for the moment.  Afrikaans has become a dead language, but it, along with Bantu, still managed to contribute several words to the Kapenaar dialect.  

Australia and New Zealand form the Viceroyalty of Australia.  Out of all of the viceroyalties it is probably closest to the version from our world.  Fiercely loyal to the Raj, but culturally more conservative, meaning closer to what we'd recognize as Victorian culture.  Their English is the closest to our own, to the point that Athelstan can't understand an Australian member of the Peshawar Lancers.  Australia has a colony in the Pacific Northwest of North America. 

Speaking of which, what happened to America?  It got hit hard by The Fall, and the resulting tsunamis.  The less effected region couldn't handle the influx of refugees, and America collapsed into Neo-Barbarism and tribalism.  There are a few civilized places; Texas has a semi-civilized tribal confederation, California is home to a series of theocratic city-states, and the Mormons are doing pretty well in Utah.  The Angrezi have a few outposts at the major rivers, but no serious settlements.  

Now let's talk about the rest of the world.  France, which is now known as France-outre-mer, evacuated to its North African colonies.  They've held onto Marseilles and a few other places in Southern France, and have retained most of their original culture.  They've also begun resettling Italy and the Iberian Peninsula, though that's being slightly complicated by the Caliphate of Damascus, the successor to the Ottoman Empire.  Egypt has managed to become independent, and acts as a buffer state between France and the Caliphate.  It's also mentioned that Brazil is doing fairly well for itself, albeit they also happen to be members of the caudillo of the month club.  The Dutch evacuated to Indonesia and exist as a client state of the Raj as the Republic of Batavia.  They've got a hybrid culture with Indonesia like the British do with India.  

The Raj's main rival for power is Dai-Nippon.  They're a union of China and Japan, and by that I mean Japan invaded China during The Fall.  They control the Japanese home isles, China, a good chunk of Eastern Asia and they have a colony on the west coast of North America.  They are ruled by a Mikado who, these days, spends just as much time, if not more, in Peking as he does in Edo.  And yeah, Beijing and Tokyo are still called Peking and Edo.  From what we glimpse it appears the Westernization has slightly reversed, with the Nippiness favoring traditional clothing, and samurai still play a role in society. 

By far the most notable resident of the post-Fall world, other than the Angrezi themselves, is the Russian Empire.  The Fall has a massive impact on the Russian psyche.  As a result, they turned their backs on Christianity and embraced Satanism.  Nobody know how exactly this happened, but it is speculated that it might be a very corrupted version the Yazidi belief in Melek Taus, the peacock angel.  Indeed, the Russians often refer to Satan as Melek Taus; though they also associate him with the Slavic god Chernobog.  

Russia retreated to their Central Asian territories, and their capital is Samarkand.  Russia makes a point of keeping its Kazakh and Uzbek subjects terrified and in-line by, among other things, eating them.  At one point Count Ignatieff, the main villain of the book, looks forward to getting home to Samarkand to enjoy a delicious suckling Uzbek.  So yeah, the Russians literally eat babies. 

The one of the most notable features of the Russian Empire are the Sisters of the True Dreamer.  They're descended from a nun who had psychic powers, which they all inherited.  Boys go mad around puberty, but girls keep for several years before their madness sets in.  The madness can be averted with sex, but that also removes their powers, so the Russians make a point of ensuring that doesn't happen.  You might wonder why they never try to run away, but there could be several reason for this.  If the girls never see themselves getting away in their dream, they won't try, and thus you get a self-fulfilling prophecy.  Alternatively, they do try, but their sisters rat them out.  The Sisters are the one true fantasy element in an otherwise mostly steampunk-lite sort of novel.  There is one particularly amusing scene where Yasmini gets a glimpse of several alternate worlds, including our world. 

So, how is this story for realism?  Well, perhaps not the most realistic, but that's not necessarily a bad thing.  The asteroid that killed the dinosaurs was about the size of Mount Everest, so I'm not sure if humanity could have realistically survived The Fall.  Of course, that depends on how much total mass those asteroids amounted to.  Stirling has said that he wrote The Peshawar Lancers because he want to write something that like the adventures stories of Rudyard Kipling, which you can't really do in the modern explored world; but he also wanted to avoid the disappointment of historical fiction. 

He knew what he wanted to happen, built the story around that, and the book is all the better for that.  As you may have guess, I adore the worldbuilding Sterling put into this book.  This book is often described as being steampunk, but I'm not sure if I entirely sure if I agree with that label.  It is certainly true that the book includes several things often found in steampunk works, such as airships and Babbage Engines, but for the most part the technology is typical Victorian and Edwardian stuff. Of course, in the grand scheme of things, the exact labeling is fairly inconsequential.  At the end of the book there is a very large appendix that really fleshes out the details of the history of this alternate world.  

It was kind of amazing to think that Athelstan and Cassandra, both in their mid-twenties, were about the same age as me when I was reading this book.  I felt the same way about Jazz Bashara when I read Artemis, which I will get around to reviewing at some point.  Prince Charles was, I would say, probably different from the Prince Charles of our world.  He certainly sounds younger and more handsome than the Prince Charles of our world.  Well, that and he's the son of King-Emperor John II, who has no analogue in our world that I can think of.  One touch I liked is that the British Royal Family is still called Saxe-Coburg Gotha.  Germany was destroyed during The Fall, and thus World War I never happened, so they never changed their name to Windsor.  

Cassandra's romantic struggles give us insight into the society of the Raj.  It's mentioned that women have made considerable strides and advances, but they still lack the vote.  Cassandra is attracted to Charles, but if she marries him, she'll have to give up her hard-won position at the university.  So it seems that, beneath the adventure and exoticism, the Raj still has its share of issues to sort out.  Of course, for me personally, the lack of air conditioning would be a real killer.   

I haven't really been talking about the characters.  That not because I thought they were bad, or that I didn't enjoy them.  I did, very much so, but when I think of The Peshawar Lancers I always think first and foremost about the amazing worldbuilding.  Hey, if nothing else, it gives you something to discover when you read this book. 

I would also like to take a moment to plug the awesome audiobook version.  The audiobook version is, of course, the whole reason we're having this review.  It is narrated by Shaun Grindell, who perfectly captures the story.  I'm very happy that this amazing work of alternate history is available in audiobook form at long last.  

Well, there you have it.  I've been waiting for The Peshawar Lancers to come out in audio for quite some time, and it was well worth the wait.  Easily one of the best alternate history novels I've read in a while.  Well, I think that should do it for now.  I will see you guys next time.